CATEGORY: Best Supporting Actor

NOMINEES:
1. Aaron Douglas as Galen "Chief" Tyrol
2. Richard Hatch as Tom Zarek
3. Michael Hogan as Saul Tigh
4. Tahmoh Penikett as Karl "Helo" Agathon
5. Donnelly Rhodes and Doc Cottle
 

WINNER: Aaron Douglas as Galen "Chief" Tyrol

CATEGORY: Most Shocking Moment

NOMINEES:
1. Adama and Cain's simultaneous assassination plots against each other (Res Ship pt. I)
2. Gina surprising Cain in her quarters and executing her ("Res Ship pt. II")
3. Lt. Thorne’s attempt to rape Sharon ("Pegasus")
4. Revelation of a "One Year Later" time jump ("LDYB pt. II")
5. Tyrol beating the frak out of Cally when he wakes up from his nightmare ("LDYB pt. I")

WINNER: Tyrol beating the frak out of Cally when he wakes up from his nightmare ("LDYB pt. I")